Sales teams review lost deals by inspecting the proposal. That's the wrong artifact. The deal died earlier, and the proposal just recorded the time of death.
🎧 Hear this post
Most enterprise deals are decided before the proposal is written, which means most sales teams are optimizing the part of the cycle that matters least.
The proposal gets the attention. It has templates, reviewers, pricing models, version control. Sales managers coach reps on it. Deals that lose are reviewed by looking at the proposal. By the time the proposal is being built, the outcome is usually already known — and known by the customer, not the seller.
The decision lives in the first conversation. Specifically, in whether the buyer left that conversation believing three things: this person understands my problem, this person has seen my situation before, this person is going to make my life easier next quarter. If all three are yes, the proposal is a formality. If any one is no, the proposal is a eulogy.
Reps who lose deals in the first call usually don’t know they lost. The call ended politely. A follow-up was scheduled. Materials were sent. The reported outcome is “deal in progress.” The actual outcome was decided around minute eleven — when the rep said something that revealed the industry wasn’t familiar, or the use case hadn’t been seen before, or the implementation was going to be the customer’s problem.
The customer was not going to tell the rep. The customer was going to take the meeting, accept the proposal, and pick the other vendor.
Three things that kill deals in the first conversation, all survivable if caught, none of them coachable via a better proposal:
One — asking questions the customer’s website would have answered. Signals the rep didn’t prepare, which signals the account is not important.
Two — describing the product before understanding the problem. The customer has heard the pitch. What they haven’t heard is a specific reason to believe this vendor will make month two easier than month one.
Three — promising flexibility on terms before the problem is defined. Reads as eagerness. Eagerness reads as weakness. Weakness reads as this vendor will be a vendor, not a partner.
The way to win more deals is not a better proposal. It is a better first call. Sales organizations that review lost deals by inspecting the proposal are examining the wrong artifact — the deal died earlier, and the proposal just recorded the time of death.
If the first call doesn’t produce this person has seen my situation before, the rest of the funnel is cleanup.
0 Comments