Most ops dashboards are not lying. They are showing the company exactly what the company asked to see two years ago.
🎧 Hear this post
Most ops dashboards are decorative.
Not because the numbers are wrong, but because the dashboard was built to confirm what leadership already believes. Red means something needs attention. Green means it doesn’t. The problem is that nobody audits what green is measuring.
At one mid-market services company, four headline metrics had stayed green for three quarters: on-time delivery, ticket resolution time, NPS, and gross margin. A senior operator asked why the team felt stretched if everything was on track. Nobody could answer.
The audit took ninety minutes.
On-time delivery was measured against an SLA that had been renegotiated downward fourteen months earlier — the new bar was lower, so the same performance looked better. Ticket resolution time counted from assignment, not from customer report; tickets sat unassigned for a day and a half. NPS was surveyed only among customers who had logged in recently, filtering out the ones who had stopped showing up. Gross margin was reported before allocating the support hours the flagship product consumed.
Every metric was green. Every metric was technically accurate. The business was bleeding.
The pattern: a dashboard tells the truth about what it measures, but a metric is a choice about what to measure, and choices age. The metric built two years ago to catch a specific problem is still running today against a different business, and nobody has re-asked whether it is watching the right thing.
Three questions worth printing next to the dashboard:
One — when was this metric last redefined? If the answer is never or I don’t know, the metric is probably measuring the 2023 business, not this one.
Two — what would have to go wrong for this to turn red? If the answer is a scenario that can’t actually happen — because the denominator quietly excludes it, or the threshold was softened — the metric is cosmetic.
Three — who has incentive for this to stay green? That person is often also the one who proposed the definition. That is not a conspiracy. It is gravity.
A dashboard isn’t lying to the company. It’s showing the company exactly what the company asked to see. The question is whether anyone in the room still remembers what they were asking for.
0 Comments